Updated on June 21, 2023 | April 9, 2020
Do you know what our most popular Specialty Pizza is? If you guessed Taco, surprisingly, you'd be wrong. It's actually (drum roll please), our Supreme Pizza!
But what makes our Supreme so… well, supreme with our guests? Maybe it's because it lets you have it all within one pizza, or maybe it's because Casey's Supreme Pizza is even more delicious than the other pizza chains' Supreme options. We think it's both!
You may be questioning what sets our Supreme Pizzas apart from the rest. We believe it's our made-from-scratch mentality, along with our delicious & fresh ingredients.
We pride ourselves on using 100% mozzarella cheese and the freshest hand-cut veggies in the neighborhood like the mushrooms, green peppers and black olives you would find on our Supreme Pizza. Plus we offer quality cuts of beef, pepperoni, and even our signature hot and mild sausage with recipes developed by our incredible culinary team.
We also let you choose your crust preference – from our handmade original, crispy thin crust, gluten-free, and even garlic crust – each option is tasty in its own way. While other establishments may offer similar Supreme Pizza, no one else offers exactly the same mouthwatering ingredient combinations that Casey's does.
If Supreme isn't quite your thing, we have some clever ideas for you to customize this special into something you will love just as much.
We heard from one guest that his wife's favorite go-to pizza is Supreme, but that he couldn't care less about green peppers, black olives, or onions, so he opted to remove those toppings from half of the pizza.
Once he did, he ended up with a side of pizza that almost resembled our Meat Galore option (instead of ham, it just had mushrooms). His wife was able to have the Supreme Pizza she was craving and he was able to enjoy some pizza that better suited his tastes. Win-win!
We love hearing our guests’ innovative ideas for customizing our pizzas to fit their unique tastes. It’s a super efficient way for you to save some money and still please the whole family!
Interested in customizing your next order? When you add a pizza to your cart, simply hit the drop-down menu to select which toppings you want and on which side of the pizza you want it. Then checkout as usual.
What are some other delicious combinations you want to try? Let us know all your great ideas on Facebook!
Casey's always has many great deals going on so you can enjoy your favorites for even less! Take a peek at our deals page to find deals of our Specialty Pizzas (like the fan-favorite Supreme!), as well as sides, desserts, drinks, and more!
