Casey's General Stores, Inc

Create Your Own Ultimate Casey's Pizza

Updated on May 10, 2022 | October 2, 2020

Board of pizza toppings to choose from for creating your own pizza

Here at Casey’s, October is our favorite month, and it’s not because of pumpkin spice or trick-or-treating (although we do enjoy those things, too) but because it’s National Pizza Month!

You might have heard that delicious pizza is pretty much our thing. Pepperoni, Taco Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza – you name it, we have perfected the flavor with made-from-scratch crust and high-quality, fresh ingredients.

Our team of culinary leaders are always daydreaming of mouthwatering combinations to bring to our fans, but now we want to know… which pizza combination that you’ve created is your favorite?

Win Free Pizza for a Year!

Note: this sweepstakes is no longer available. Subscribe to our emails to be the first to hear about all of our contests, sweepstakes, and more!

This month we launched Casey’s Create Your Own Ultimate Pizza Sweepstakes! Guests can enter the sweepstakes on our site and let us know their tastiest pizza recipes. One lucky winner will win FREE pizza for a whole year, and four runner-up entries will win FREE pizza for 6 months. That’s a whole lot of easy, delicious dinners you won’t have to cook!

And who knows… we might just ask for your creation to be the next showcased limited-time pizza on our menu!

While this sweepstakes is no longer running, we are always interested in hearing your favorite pizza combinations! Share your personal favorites with us on Facebook for a chance to be featured.

Need some inspiration? Check out some of our favorite pizza combos below that you can create yourself with our Create Your Own Pizza option.

Our Favorite Pizza Combinations

Italian Grinder Pizza

Italian Grinder Pizza

  • Original Crust
  • Marinara Sauce
  • Mozzarella Cheese
  • Sausage (mild or hot)
  • Onions
  • Banana Peppers

Chef Farrokh from Casey’s culinary innovation team highlights one of his favorite creations, Italian Grinder Pizza: “The mix of mouthwatering flavors turns a classic sandwich into a custom one-of-a-kind pizza that is sure to knock some socks off.”

ORDER NOW


Margherita Pizza

Margherita Pizza

  • Flatbread Crust
  • Marinara Sauce
  • Mozzarella Cheese
  • Tomatoes
  • Spinach

This next creation is a classy favorite that you can order with our Create Your Own Pizza option: Margherita Pizza!

Our culinary team recommends trying a Margherita Pizza on our flatbread crust to give the pizza an extra crunch, or add some chicken for a little extra protein.

ORDER NOW


Spicy Trio Pizza

Spicy Trio Pizza

  • Original Crust
  • Marinara Sauce
  • Mozzarella Cheese
  • Pepperoni
  • Hot Sausage
  • Jalapenos

If you're someone who likes a little heat, we have the perfect creation for you. Nicknamed the Spicy Trio Pizza, this is a new fave from our team member Stacy who is a big fan of some spice on her pizza.

Can your taste buds handle this mouthwatering (and slightly eye-watering) mix of flavors?

ORDER NOW


CREATE YOUR OWN PIZZA

It's time to make your own personal creation!

START PIZZA CREATION


 

© 2022 Casey's General Stores, Inc. All Rights Reserved.