Updated on November 12, 2025 | November 1, 2019
Deals and product offerings valid at time of posting, please check our current deals page for all current pizza, food, and drink deals, and our menu for all current product offerings.
Here at Casey's, we're always trying to find delicious new pizza flavors for our guests to enjoy. Recently, our culinary team has been working hard on perfecting some soul-satisfying flavors we all love (think creamy pasta dishes like your grandma used to make) and revamping them into mouthwatering pizza form!
We're excited to announce that starting this month we'll be adding two very special pizzas to our menu for a limited time.
“Miss the mac and cheese pizza, bring it back. Pl‑ease”
–Angela R.
Good news, Angela, we heard you, and we're bringing the Mac & Cheese Pizza back for a limited time!
This returning fan-favorite combines two cheesy favorites into the ultimate dinner special. The tasty mashup of flavor features a creamy cheddar cheese sauce and classic macaroni and cheese on top of our famous made-from-scratch crust, then topped with 100% whole milk mozzarella cheese. Talk about cheesy!
Alone, this is enough to make it delectably delicious, but you can also add additional toppings to customize it to your favorite taste – try bacon, beef, grilled chicken, or any of your other favorite pizza toppings to create your own personal Mac & Cheese Pizza masterpiece!
See if this delicious pizza made the list our guest's Top 5 Limited-Time Specialty Pizzas!
“When creating the Chicken Alfredo Pizza, we knew it had to feature top-notch ingredients and be unique. We found an alfredo sauce that features real heavy cream, aged parmesan cheese, and garlic for an authentic and rich sauce that pairs perfectly with our signature grilled chicken. We then topped the pizza with fresh spinach, and we knew we found a winner!”
-Team Member Andrew K.
Is your mouth watering yet for the new Chicken Alfredo Pizza? Do you ever crave a pizza without marinara sauce? If you do, then you'll absolutely love this specialty pizza!
We believe this will be a huge crowd-pleaser because it satisfies two Italian cravings in one yummy dish. And like Andrew mentioned, this pizza is packed with rich flavor you won't be able to find anywhere else. We can't wait for our guests to try it, but make sure you don't miss out – this is only available for a short time.
While this pizza is unfortunately not currently available, try our fan-favorite Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizza!
So, which new pizza are you going to try first? Make ordering one of our specialty pizzas easier than ever by either using our mobile app, calling a store near you, or ordering online.
You can pick carryout and grab one on your way home, or you can have your pizza delivered straight to your front door, and one of our drivers will make sure to get your pizza to you FAST.
Subscribe to email to discover exclusive offers and deals on pizza and other favorites – sent right to your inbox!
