Casey's General Stores, Inc

Preview

FPO: How to Reheat Leftover Pizza

Updated on January 18, 2023 | August 11, 2022

View post titled FPO: How to Reheat Leftover Pizza

If you are lucky enough to have leftover Casey’s pizza to enjoy later, you should also know the best way to reheat it.

Maybe you’re like most Americans and pop it in the microwave, take a guess on how many seconds it needs to heat up, and hope for the best. But, our pizza deserves better and so do you. 😉

Don't worry! We have all the pro tips to make your day-old pizza taste as good as if you just walked out the door with it today. Take a look below for all the options you need of how to reheat your leftover Casey's pizza.

 

How to Reheat Pizza in the Oven

Some call this the 'best way' to reheat your leftover slices, and we can't say we disagree. While this method takes longer than others, it’s worth the little extra time to ensure a tender crust and perfectly melted cheese.

Expert Steps:

  1. Move your cold pizza to a baking sheet
  2. Cover the baking sheet with aluminum foil and seal tightly
  3. Place the sheet on the lowest rack of your oven
  4. Set the oven temperature to 275 degrees Fahrenheit
  5. Let the pizza warm for 25-30 minutes and ENJOY!

Pro-tip: Wondering how to reheat Casey's Taco Pizza? This is the best method to help keep the tortilla chips crispy!

 

How to Reheat Pizza in a Skillet

This is an unusual but great process for reheating pizza that you might not think of! If you only have a few slices to reheat, but still want a quality way to warm them, this is the perfect choice.

Expert Steps:

  1. Heat skillet over medium heat
  2. Add pizza slices to skillet and cook for 2-3 minutes, uncovered
  3. Then, add a few drops of water to the pan (avoid getting your pizza wet!)
  4. Cover the pan and cook for 3-4 more minutes, or until your cheese is melty

 

How to Reheat Pizza in the Air Fryer

In a time crunch? For similar results as your oven or stovetop, but in less time, the air fryer works great for reheating purposes. No need for monitoring or preheating!

Expert Steps:

  1. Line basket or tray with aluminum foil or parchment paper
  2. Spray the top of your pizza with cooking spray to that toppings don't dry out
  3. Arrange the pizza on top of aluminum foil
  4. Air fry your pizza at about 350 degrees for 3 minutes

 

How to Reheat Pizza on the Grill

Can you say yum!? Reheating a slice or two on the grill is a delicious option to give your pizza a new taste! This is a decently quick option for fair weather days.

Expert Steps:

  1. Set your grill to medium-high and give it a few minutes to warm up
  2. Place pizza on the grate and let reheat for about 6 minutes

 

How to Best Reheat Pizza in the Microwave

This is the fastest and most common way to heat up leftovers, but not always the best way. If you are looking for a speedy option, try these instructions for optimizing taste while still heating your pizza up fast.

Expert Steps:

  1. Fill up a glass of water and set it in the microwave
  2. Add a paper towel on a plate, then put your slice on top (this helps decrease grease and absorb moisture!)
  3. Microwave for about 30 seconds

 

So, can pizza be reheated? The answer is YES! Next time you have leftover Casey's pizza, try all our favorite rewarming potions above and find the best way for you.

 


NO PIZZA TO REHEAT?

Order your favorite Casey's Pizza for dinner tonight! Check out all of our pizza deals.

SEE DEALS


 

© 2026 Casey's General Stores, Inc. All Rights Reserved.