Updated on December 2, 2025 | November 30, 2021
The holiday season is here, and that means it’s time for Secret Santa surprises and White Elephant laughs! Whether you're shopping for coworkers, friends, or family, Casey’s has you covered with fun, affordable, and unexpected gift ideas that are perfect for any gift exchange.
Secret Santa Gifts Under $25
- Casey’s Coffee & Cocoa Combo: Warm up their winter with a Casey’s branded coffee mug paired with a bag of ground coffee or hot cocoa mix. Add a candy cane for festive flair!
- Snack Lover’s Stocking Stuffer: Grab a mix of Casey’s favorite beef jerky, trail mix and a sweet treat like fudge or chocolate-covered pretzels. Wrap it in a holiday-themed snack sack.
- Build-Your-Own Beer Sampler: Choose 3-6 craft or seasonal beers from Casey’s beverage section. Include a mix of styles - IPA, lager, stout, or hard seltzers. Even better, Casey’s delivers and offers curbside pickup on a select variety of alcohol at select locations.
White Elephant Gifts That Spark Smiles
- “Mystery Munchie” Box: Fill a small box with a random assortment of Casey’s snacks - think spicy chips, gummy worms, and a surprise energy drink. It’s quirky, fun and unpredictable.
- Cozy Convenience Kit: Include a pair of fuzzy socks, a mini hand warmer, and a Casey’s hot drink coupon. Great for those cold Midwest mornings!
- Pizza Party Pack: Fill a basket up, a pizza cutter, a gift card and an assortment of beverages from beer to soda. It’s the gift that keeps on giving.
.png)
Choose your gift guide
Look no further, the gift guide you've been waiting for is here to help you with everyone on your holiday shopping list!
Unwrap more ideas
24 Days of Casey's Rewards
Celebrate the season with 24 days of exclusive perks through Casey’s Rewards! From daily surprises to special holiday treats, every day brings something new. Join the fun and make your holidays even brighter!
See details
Need a last-minute gift?
Casey's gift cards make the perfect last-minute gift! Pick yours up in store or order one online.
Shop now
