Casey's General Stores, Inc

5 Ways to Upgrade Your S’mores This Summer

Updated on August 14, 2023 | July 4, 2023

A cup of S'mores Campfire Coffee on a table with s'mores ingredients

S’mores are simply the best!

This easy treat is enjoyed around summer campfires galore and everyone knows the 3 ingredients that are needed: graham crackers, marshmallows, and a chocolate bar. But have you ever wondered what it would be like to mix and match the ingredients to create your own s’mores recipe? 

A close-up of a delicious S'mores

Follow along for our favorite s’mores DIYs! 

1. Add Peanut Butter

Level up with one of the best s’mores toppings! Simply make your s'more the original way but spread peanut butter over one of the graham crackers before cooking your marshmallow.

You may not know that Casey’s actually has peanut butter, but we sure do! Add it to your delivery or pickup order.

Order peanut butter


2. Swap Your Chocolate

Our mouths are watering just thinking about this… here’s how to make s’mores even more appealing: change out your chocolate choice!

An assortment of Casey's chocolate bars on a table

Here's our fave swaps:

Order chocolate


3. Make it a Salty Snack

Salty and sweet. An age-old classic!

A bag of Casey's Original Potato Chips

It may seem odd, but Casey’s original chips or pretzels crushed and sprinkled in adds extra crunch for a gourmet s’more.

Order chips


4. Change Up Your Cookie Choice

Really any Casey’s cookie will do… but what if you used our new S'mores Cookie? It's limited-time only and will take your S'more to the extreme!

Casey's limited-time S'more's Cookie

Order cookies


5. Freeze It Up!

Move aside, regular s’mores!

If you're looking for something a little cooler, try an Ice Cream S'more! Use graham crackers as normal but replace your marshmallow with ice cream and use chocolate sauce for dipping. 

Casey's Cookies & Cream Ice Cream with Oreo cookies on a table

Here are our favorite Ice Cream options:

Order ice cream


Want even ~s'more~ fun?

Pick up these fun Casey’s s’mores-flavored treats:

S’mores Campfire Coffee

Bring the campfire memories to your cup this summer with this toasty, roasty coffee.

Casey's Iced S'mores Campfire Coffee with S'mores ingredients on a table

Try it iced, hot, or in hot chocolate form!


S’mores Pie

Our newest addition to our delicious pie collection! Available only for a limited time.

An assortment of Casey's Pies including a S'mores Pie moving back and forth

S’mores Trail Mix

The perfect snack for anyone who loves the sweet and crunchy flavor of a traditional s’more but wants a little salty flavor too. 


Order S'mores Day Supplies

National S'mores Day is August 10th, so prep for a delicious, fun-filled day with all the ingredients you need for these fun creations.

Shop now


© 2024 Casey's General Stores, Inc. All Rights Reserved.